We’re weighing the most recent Nest Thermostat vs. Nest Thermostat E, two comparatively inexpensive good thermostats that function price range choices in comparison with the premium Nest Studying Thermostat. Google has stopped promoting the Nest Thermostat E besides to skilled installers, however just a few retailers nonetheless have inventory (for now), and it has been our top-ranked thermostat for years. So do you have to snatch up the older E mannequin whilst you nonetheless can, or go along with the most recent Nest Thermostat? There is a case to be made for both system.
Nest Thermostat versus Nest Thermostat E: Not a lot has modified
Supply: Daniel Bader / Android Central
The brand new Nest Thermostat could have a shiny new mirrored lens, however in most different areas you might name it a mirror picture of the Nest Thermostat E. Each lack most of the perks you get with the Nest Studying Thermostat, and a number of the enhancements of the Nest Thermostat are app-based, which means present Nest Thermostat E house owners can profit from them as properly.
For starters, each thermostats work with 85% of heating, air flow, and air-con (HVAC) programs. Neither requires a C wire to work, and each can be suitable (or incompatible) with the identical programs. Nevertheless, all Nest thermostats typically run into issues when put in and not using a C wire, so in both case it’s possible you’ll find yourself desirous to manually set up a C wire to present them a extra constant energy supply.
As soon as put in and wired into your HVAC system, Google will monitor your HVAC efficiency, measuring how lengthy it takes for the system to warmth or cool your property to the goal temperature. If it measures a drop in efficiency, you will obtain a notification warning you that it could want fixing. Whereas it is a new characteristic for the Nest Thermostat, Google has additionally added monitoring to its older thermostats too.
Each thermostats supply HVAC monitoring, geofencing, good residence compatibility, IFTTT help, and compatibility with the identical heating programs.
Whereas the 2 thermostats’ shows are pretty totally different, one similarity we’ll spotlight right here is that each are pretty low-resolution: the Nest Thermostat E is 320×320 pixels whereas the brand new Nest Thermostat is 240×320 pixels. Neither helps the Farsight know-how discovered on the Studying Thermostat that makes the temperature studying bigger while you’re standing additional away. Whichever you select, it’s possible you’ll want to face pretty near it to see the temperature clearly.
The Nest Thermostat E has some smarter scheduling choices than the Nest Thermostat (extra on that beneath), however each help geofencing and proximity sensing, so it is aware of while you’ve left residence and can robotically flip down the warmth or air to save lots of vitality whilst you’re out. Furthermore, via the Google Residence app, you may manually schedule temperature adjustments all through the day, and you will obtain recommendations from Google’s Financial savings Finder on methods you may optimize your schedule for vitality financial savings.
Need the comfort of fixing the temperature with out having to stand up? The Nest Thermostat and Thermostat E can hook up with your good speaker, so you may command Alexa or Google Assistant to alter the temperature from the sofa.
Nest Thermostat versus Nest Thermostat E: Principally incremental adjustments
Now that we have established how comparable these two good thermostats are, let’s dive into the ways in which Google has up to date its latest system — together with some adjustments that make it much less superior than the Nest Thermostat E. For starters, take a look at the side-by-side specs.
|Nest Thermostat||Nest Thermostat E|
|Dimensions||3.Three x 1.1 inches||3.19 x 1.14 inches|
|Colours||Snow, Sand, Fog, Charcoal||White|
|Trim Plate||Offered individually||Included with buy (Polycarbonate)|
|Show||2.4-inch IPS LCD with mirrored lens
|1.76-inch frosted LCD
320×320 pixels, 182 ppi
|Power Star Licensed||Sure||Sure|
|Handbook temperature adjustments||Contact strip on facet||Bodily turn-dial|
|App connectivity||Google Residence||Nest for setup; Nest or Google Residence for controls|
|Voice assistants||Alexa & Google Assistant||Alexa & Google Assistant|
|Energy||Varied HVAC system wires, 2 AAA battery backup||Varied HVAC system wires; rechargeable lithium ion battery|
|HVAC Compatibility||85% of programs||85% of programs|
|HVAC downside monitoring||Sure||Sure|
|Wi-Fi||802.11b/g/n 2.Four GHz, 802.11a/n 5 GHz Wi-Fi
|802.11 a/b/g/n 2.4GHz / 5GHz
|Turns down warmth when away from residence||Sure||Sure|
The Thermostat E has a bodily polycarbonate dial that may be turned to alter the temperature, whereas the Nest Thermostat has a contact strip on its facet that you will need to both swipe up and down on or faucet and maintain on the highest or backside to alter the temperature.
The Nest Thermostat wins the Nest magnificence contest, although neither thermostat’s show is that spectacular.
If this comparability is a magnificence contest, then the brand new Nest Thermostat would win. The shortage of the flip dial offers the newer mannequin a thinner look alongside the sting, so the show seems to fill extra of its quantity. And whereas the Thermostat E solely is available in one shade (white), the newer mannequin has 4 shade choices that’ll make it extra more likely to mix in or come out in opposition to your partitions.
As for the shows themselves, the Nest Thermostat E is considerably infamous for being tough to learn due to a low-resolution, glazed display. The brand new Nest Thermostat would not up the decision however makes a shift to a brand new IPS LCD show that may have higher facet viewing angles, and makes use of a mirrored lens that offers it a reflective sheen at any time when the show is not energetic.
To trace when to activate the show, the brand new Nest Thermostat makes use of Soli radar, the identical motion-tracking tech used within the newest Google Pixel telephones. The Nest Thermosat E has its personal proximity and occupancy sensors to find out when to activate, however we will not say for sure if Soli or these unnamed sensors are higher than the opposite. Theoretically, Soli could also be extra correct because it’s newer.
Solely the Nest Thermostat E will construct a heating and cooling schedule for you.
Google has migrated its new thermostat interface away from the Nest app to Google Residence, so the brand new Nest Thermostat is simply suitable with the Residence app. The Nest Thermostat E can solely be arrange with the Nest app, however from there you may select between the Nest app or the Residence app for scheduling and controls.
A very powerful distinction between the 2 is that the Nest Thermostat E, just like the Nest Studying Thermostat, tracks your vitality utilization and adjustments earlier than robotically producing a personalised temperature schedule to your residence. With the Nest Thermostat 2020, you will need to manually program a schedule earlier than Google can begin sending you non-obligatory financial savings tweaks.
Lastly, the Nest Thermostat E works with distant sensors that permit you to measure particular temperatures all through your property. When you’re keen to pay further for them, these sensors are helpful to watch bigger houses the place the temperature varies from room to room. Sadly, the brand new Nest Thermostat is not suitable with them, making it a greater match for smaller houses or residences.
Nest Thermostat versus Nest Thermostat E: Do not improve, however contemplate shopping for new
When you already personal the Nest Thermostat E, there actually is not any case to be made that you must exchange it with the brand new Nest Thermostat. There simply aren’t sufficient variations between them to make it value uninstalling and reinstalling a brand new system only for the sake of a extra colourful show.
The Nest Thermostat is a worthy various if the Thermostat E goes out of inventory.
Buyers on the lookout for a brand new system have a harder resolution. Each thermostats are pretty comparable in worth and options, and gives you the identical vitality financial savings in the long term. The Nest Thermostat 2020 will look prettier in your wall and has higher Google Residence app help, however the Nest Thermostat E makes the preliminary post-installation interval straightforward by constructing a schedule for you. In the end, we do not suppose both buy is the unsuitable selection, and if the Thermostat E is not in inventory, the brand new Nest Thermostat is a worthy various.
As a sidenote, we’ll additionally level out that the Nest Studying Thermostat can be value a glance if you happen to can afford it. Verify our Nest Studying Thermostat versus Nest Thermostat E and Nest Studying Thermostat versus new Nest Thermostat breakdowns for extra info on the third good thermostat on this gifted gadget household.
Nonetheless our favourite
Nest Thermostat E
The Nest Thermostat E is the one price range thermostat that mimics the Studying Thermostat’s automated scheduling tech, serving to to simply cut back your electrical invoice. It is top-of-the-line good thermostats you should purchase.
Colourful and revitalized
Google Nest Thermostat
Constructed to work together with your Google Residence app and good speaker, the Nest Thermostat 2020 trusts you to determine your vitality saving schedule for your self, and can look a lot snazzier in your wall.
We could earn a fee for purchases utilizing our hyperlinks. Learn more.